thbeales

On “Big Edie” Beale’s death bed her daughter “Little Edie” asked her if there was anything she wanted to say. According to Little Edie she replied “There’s nothing more to say, it’s all in the film.” Groundbreaking documentary filmmakers The Maysles Brothers presented Big and Little Edie Beale to the world in 1975 with the splendid documentaryGrey Gardens, a film that rivets you where you need to be riveted, if you’ve got the groove for it.

The Beales were former socialites who created a world of their own when faced with poverty and social ostracism. Their closest friends were mostly an army of cats and raccoons until The Maysles showed up. Highly educated in the arts and used to a life of decadence, the Beales carried on for the camera in front of filth and dilapidation as if nothing at all was the matter.

“VLADIMIR: What do they say?
ESTRAGON: They talk about their lives.
VLADIMIR: To have lived is not enough for them.
ESTRAGON: They have to talk about it.”
?-Samuel Beckett, Waiting for Godot

Although they had holed away together for decades, their exile from their tony community worsened in the early 1970s after their mansion was condemned and their relative Jacqueline Kennedy Onassis and her husband Ari stepped in, spending $32,000, to help get it back in order. The Maysles filmed with the Beales after the highly publicized renovation, which is almost hard believe with the state of the house documented on film: the rooms were in disarray and cats seemed to be coming out of the walls (raccoons definitely were.) At one point, perhaps the most hilarious moment of the film, Big Edie catches a cat going to the bathroom behind a large and gorgeous portrait of herself. Instead of regret or lamentations about this rather disgusting turn of events, Big Edie simply says “At least someone’s having fun.” A cat defacating behind a work of art and symbol of class and stature is both hilarious and poignant.

With the prevalence of reality television and the popularity of documentaries at a peak, we’re now used to literally being invited into people’s homes and lives through the screen, especially if there is some sort of dysfunction invovled, but the intimate style of the film was groundbreaking at the time. It showed a rare portrait of two ladies who were locked away from the world in a kind of Waiting for Godot existential dance full of song and melodrama. They seemed to be reliving the past on a loop, and bickering to the point of nonsense. As Little Edie so poetically put it, “It’s very difficult to keep the line between the past and the present.” During filming Little Edie wallows in regret, threatening to leave to Paris or New York. She dreams of finding a husband, but the truth is she is bound here. She did not (could not) leave Grey Gardens until her mother left.

“ESTRAGON: I can’t go on like this.
VLADIMIR: That’s what you think.”
? Samuel Beckett, Waiting for Godot

“Big” Edith Ewing Bouvier Beale was Jacqueline’s aunt, the sister of the first lady’s dad “Black Jack” Bouiver. All her life, Edie wanted to be a singer, but in 1917 her aspirations were put on hold when she married Wall Street lawyer Phelan Beale. The pair lived together for a while on Madison Avenue in NYC, at the current site of the Carlyle Hotel. She gave birth to “Little Edie” Bouvier Beale the same year, followed by brothers Phelan Beale, Jr. in 1920, and Bouvier Beale in 1922. The family purchased Grey Gardens in East Hampton in 1923, and Edith and the children settled in there while Phelan continued to work in NYC.

While in the Hamptons Big Edie kept her singing dreams alive by training her mezzo-soprano voice. She performed recitals at Grey Gardens and sang at local functions, but her efforts never materialized into a career. Her marriage to Phelan Beale crumbled in 1932, and in the divorce she was left Grey Gardens and child support, but no alimony.

As the children grew up and her money dwindled, she further complicated her financial situation in 1942 when she angered her father Major John Vernou Bouvier, Jr. by showing up late to one of her son’s weddings late dressed like an opera star. He mostly cut her out of his will a few days later, leaving his daughter only a $65,000 trust.

edithewingbouiverbeale

While Big Edie was staring financial hardships in the face, and still spending frivolously, the beautiful Little Edie Beale was trying to make a showbiz life for herself in NYC.

ediebeale

When she returned to Grey Gardens in her mid-thirties it wasn’t the first time Little Edie had been called home to mother. She had spent her 11th and 12th years at home with Big Edie instead of going to school due to an undefined “respiratory illness.” While she was home those two years mother and daughter spent their time going to the movies, theatre, and taking in other art and shows. During Little Edie’s glorious convalescence, she got bit with the acting bug in a bad way. She even kept a diary during this time that you can read on Kindle, which provides a great deal of insight into Little Edie’s life and mind at the time.

bigandlittleedie

“I can’t really tell you if I am pretty or what kind of girl I am but … I have long hair, blonde, getting darker, deep blue eyes, a pug nose and a rather decided mouth,” she wrote about her body. “I am by no means fat, but I have a good body and big feet.”

She even wrote about love, both for a boy and for her mother. “There are lots of 11-year-old children who think they know the meaning of love, when they honestly haven’t any idea,” she writes. “I have two great loves in my life. First, I love my mother, which will always go on, never be forgotten or forsaken. Most children think that mother love is a thing taken for granted, isn’t it? Second, my buzzing love for a boy, no mere crush, but a true, steady love.”

Despite this young, buzzing love, Little Edie was already showing a fierce devotion to Big Edie. She said she always signed letters to her mother “With ladles and ladles of kisses, loves & hugs—your ever precious, ever loving and ever darling and kissable Edes.”

In 1934, at age 16, Little Edie went to Miss Porter’s, the posh boarding school that Mad Men‘s Sally Draper fell in love with (in fact, there are some striking similarities between Sally and Betty Draper and the Beales,) in Farmington, Connecticut.

“Vladimir: Did I ever leave you?
Estragon: You let me go.”
? Samuel Beckett, Waiting for Godot

By age 17 Little Edie was getting some modeling gigs, which scandalized her father Phelan, who was desperate to stay in good graces with his father-in-law and boss. He was already in a delicate situation because Big Edie had shunned the buttoned-up social life expected of her for what she called an “artistic life.” When she did attend events, she shocked everyone by talking about Christian Science and bursting into song.

littleediebody


By the time Little Edie was an older teenager away at boarding school and hoping to become a model or a star, her father’s business was floundering a bit because of The Great Depression. In a letter home to Big Edie, who he was in the middle of divorcing, Phelan told her to not let Little Edie in on the their gloomy financial situation. “She will think we’re at the poorhouse,” he wrote Big Edie. “It will rob all her joy.” He ended the letter by saying that he hoped he would die in an airplane crash. “I do hope that the machine crashes, because it would be a pleasant exit for a very tired man.” It’s this idea from Edie’s parents that she should be shielded from realities of life that kept her suspended in an illusion. Sometimes we thing we’re protected our loved ones by hiding things from them, but facing difficult things is an important part of being able to carve out a place in the world for ourselves.

bouiver3beale

How did Little Edie lose her hair?

At some point in her teens Little Edie suffered from alopecia, a disorder of sudden hair loss. Her hair grew back before she started modeling, and she thought she was over the condition for good, but she started losing her hair again at age 35 when her mother called her home in 1952. Her cousin John Davis claims he witnessed Edie climb a tree during this time, and set her hair on fire just to spite her mother. Regardless of what really happened, once Edie started going bald again in her thirties she never let herself be seen without a stylish head covering that matched her “costume of the day.”

Sometimes when we’re under stress, our bodies show it when we refuse to deal with it psychologically. Hair loss is linked to stress, and it seems doubtful that Little Edie’s underlying anxieties didn’t at least have something to do with her hair loss.

“Estragon: I’m like that. Either I forget right away or I never forget.”
? Samuel Beckett, Waiting for Godot

Why did Little Edie have to go back home?

In the 40s Big Edie suffered the consequences of ignoring her financial situation, and had undergone several eye operations. In a state of desperation, she pleaded with her daughter to come home to her to help her.

She could no longer afford to pay for Little Edie’s groceries at the Barbizon Hotel, a woman’s hotel young women boarded while they tried to make their dreams come true. Little Edie came home because of all the pressure, and because she couldn’t afford to feed and pay for herself, but she carried with her a deep resentment. She says she had an audition with the Broadway producer Max Gordan that summer, and could not go to it because she had to be home with her mother. “The minute he saw me, he said, ‘You’re a musical comedienne.’ I said, ‘That’s funny, I did Shakespearean tragedy at Spence.’ Max Gordon said the two were very close. I was all set to audition for the Theatre Guild that summer,” Little Edie told her friend Gail Sheehy. “I modeled for Bach¬rach while I was waiting for the summer to audition. Someone squealed to my father. Do you know, he marched up Madison Avenue and saw my picture and put his fist right through Mr. Bachrach’s window!” You kind of get the feeling, though, that not going to this audition maybe was a relief to her. It was a relief to have an excuse for why her dreams had not come true.

Why didn’t they leave their home?

In order to survive in these circumstances, Big and Little Edie could have sold their sprawling home, and paid for a smaller place in a cheaper part of the country, but Big Edie refused such a path. She clung to the property as if it was her soul. There are moments in the Maysles documentary when they are out on the balcony sunning themselves and looking out at the lush tree and the view of the Atlantic Ocean. In that context, Big Edie’s staunch refusal to leave almost makes sense. From what’s been pieced together, Big Edie lived her life both expecting everything, and refusing to make the compromises you sometimes have to make to have the things you want. Even in a world where money flows like champagne, no one is entitled to living large without realizing the costs. In the end, Big Edie wanted luxury, she wanted to stay in her giant mansion, and she wanted to maintain a hold on something she had deeply engrained in her ego. Relinquishing it at this point, would have been relinquishing a huge part of herself. She could not get the luxury with no money, so she chose to live a Miss Havisham existence in a house she could not keep up. It wasn’t just the luxury, or the dignity, it was an attachment to a place.

“Nothing happens. Nobody comes, nobody goes. It’s awful.”
? Samuel Beckett, Waiting for Godot

Little Edie never married, but says she had a stream of rich suitors like Howard Hughes and J. Paul Getty, and claims to have been engaged to John Kennedy’s brother Joe Kennedy Jr. despite the fact that they only met once. She’s said to have told Joe Kennedy Sr. at John F. Kennedy’s inauguration that if Joe Kennedy had not died in combat, she would have been First Lady instead of Jackie. According to her letters and diaries, in the late 40s she had an affair with Julius Albert Krug, the U.S. Secretary of the Interior, who was married.

Did Little Edie suffer from mental illness?

At one point in the Maysles’ footage Little Edie is seen reacting to being called a schizophrenic by the press. This diagonsis-by-media doesn’t seem to be correct, but there does seem to be some mental health issues going on with The Beales. Little Edie was enamored with both The Catholic Church and astrology, but it seems she never sought out official counseling or diagnosis.

ediebealegreygardensposter

What happened after the movie?

Big Edie enjoyed quite a bit of attention after Grey Gardens premiered, and much of the immediate aftermath of the movie was documented by family friend, and fellow hermit, Lois Wright. She moved in with them for a year and kept a diligent diary.

After her mother died in 1977, Little Edie stayed at Grey Gardens for another two years. During that time she had an eight show cabaret act at a club in Greenwich Village that had terrible reviews, but gave her another moment in the spotlight. Without her mother around to keep an iron grip on the place, Little Edie sold Grey Gardens for $220,000 on the condition that it not be demolished. The current owners now rent it out or $125,000-a-week. After years of renovations, it’s now a breathtaking estate, but oit took several years alone just to get out the smell from the cats and the raccoons.

ediebealecats

So, if you’re rich enough, Grey Gardens is still there. You can walk the same rooms as the Beales. The ladies themselves believed in ghosts, and if such a thing were to exist, you can bet Big Edie is still there, ready to perform for you. Little Edie’s ghost is probably out roaming the world. That was always more her style, anyway.

To truly be haunted by Grey Gardens, however, all you have to do is watch the film. It flickers on and on for an audience who just wants stay there forever with the Beales.

A restored version of Grey Gardens was rereleased for a limited theatrical run March 6, 2015, which in a strange coincidence, happened to be the weekend Albert Mayseles passed away at him home at age 88.

—————

  • justine

    it has enriched my life knowing about these two women they are part of my life forever.

  • daboopmeister

    Wonderful documentary. Not fair little Eydie had no husband or children and found dead. So sad’

  • irishlass

    Watched the documentary last night on tcm. Found it to be absolutely fascinating. They really lived for one another without ever admitting it. Would have loved to have met them both.

    • First Mate Cate

      So would I!!

  • First Mate Cate

    I’ve been entranced by the story of Little Edie for years now. I so wish I been aware of her during her life…I would have found a way to tell her how intriguing, talented, funny, intelligent…and pretty she was.

    I’ve read so many articles about the Beales but this writing by Lynn Cinnamon has opened many secret doors to their lives. And, of course I crave more but for this, I want to thank you!

    Kind regards,
    Catherine Gray

  • Lilithcat

    “Some fans of the documentary may be surprised to know that the Maysles filmed with the Beales after the highly publicized renovation.”

    Only if they weren’t paying attention. The chronology is quite clear from the very beginning of the film.

    • Poor choice of words, so I reworked them. Wasn’t trying to express that the chronology wasn’t clear in the film, but that the state of the house was still quite bad during filming.

  • L.S. King

    I just saw the documentary on Lulu. I was most intrigued about the obvious detachment to the pitiful state of their surroundings. It was as if in their minds there was nothing wrong with their living conditions. Life was song, dance, cat walks, (pardon the pun) and confrontations that had no resolutions… but neither were grudges held. Little E, and Big E seemed to be afflicted by the same malady. In this case, and to their detriment, it made it impossible for one to help the other. On the other hand, they lived in a sort of oblivious bliss, unaware of the slippery slope that their lives were. It seem very disturbing to the viewer, but I am sure it was of no concequence to them. As they lived in their own little bubble where rules regarding cleaningness, modesty, pet care, any many other mundane things we take for granted did not apply. One thing did come through very clear; the deep affection these two had for each other, dysfunctional as it was, it was touching and endearing. I hope they both found in the next realm what eluded them in this life, true & everelasting joy in the presence of God.

  • Karen Allen

    Thank you, Lynn Cinnamon, for elucidating the many sticky points about Big Edie and Little Edie’s relationship. Finding these films, these people, and then reading your insightful article about them have helped me to better understand my own situation, as I have always felt like an outsider to the world because my own mother raised me in a similarly insular way. But as rich and slovenly as the Beales were, we were poor, and we took great pride on our tidiness, starkness, cleanliness and thrift, while we enjoyed our suffering and pain as much as the Beales enjoyed their family recitals. Like Little Edie I had to forsake my big break (an art scholarship) in order to help support my mother. Ever since I can remember I have been charged with putting my mother’s needs above my own, and watching Big Edie manipulate Little Edie has helped me to realize why she needed to, and eventually how she managed to completely control her daughter’s life. . .

    • Stanley Goldstein

      Karen: Honey, even if you had exercised the art scholarship, you’d more than likely, be in the same boat. So, don’t blame your mother.

  • Dec2963-female

    I watched the movie version with Jessica Lange and Drew Barrymore on Hulu last night. They both were Outstanding in their roles. I was especially impressed with Drew Barrrymore’s performance as “little” Edie. There are however sections of the movie that do not match the real story as told here, as well as some other articles. It is somewhat disappointing they didn’t try to stay true to the story as a whole. I watched the Documentary many years ago and was drawn in by these two eccentric women. They were very endearing in an odd sort of way.

  • Farrah Daigle

    Absolutely love the film. Their determination to be who they were was amazing. The film was great

  • Debra

    Just saw the movie for the first time. Never heard of The two ladies until I googled them, how eccentric they were! The movie kept me watching, wondering, what would be their end.
    After reading your info. it’s amazing Big Edith didn’t die sooner, with the house in the condition it was in and all the health violations. Thank God for Jackie, they may not have lasted cleaning the home probably added years to her life.

  • Cynthia Blatherwick

    A very disturbing film, exploitative of mental illness. I was fascinated and repulsed, without the Bouvier name no one would be interested in these cat ladies. The filth, the degradation, the isolation they lived in was unforgivable, who lets their family members live like this, detached from reality living in squalor. Shame on them and shame on the film-makers for exploiting their illness for gain. That said, Big Edie and Little Edie were larger than life and full of artistic expression and creativity, I must say that i admired both of them far more than their family members Jackie and Lee who had all the resources to help them live a life of dignity!

    • Stanley Goldstein

      Cynthia: Sweetie, the family members had their hands full taking care of their own lives. There’s a little thing out there, we like to call “social welfare” and if the ladies of Grey Gardens really needed it, they could have taken what they were entitled to by law, otherwise, why should the family (extended or otherwise) shoulder the unending burden? Families are far overrated for the task you wish to impose.

      • Cynthia Blatherwick

        Stanley, deary,the family should shoulder their responsibilities because they are the FAMILY, otherwise they are not family but uncaring relatives. When there is enough money to help, help can be found!

        • Stanley Goldstein

          My biological family members are back biting, vipers. Thank God’s older brother, I was adopted out of that family.

          • Cynthia Blatherwick

            As a child I would pray nightly for my Mother to enact her threats to send me to a convent. How wonderful it would be to escape the large, messy, noisy and horrible clan of clowns, buffoons, idiots ,the menacing undercurrent of violence about to erupt. I left as soon as I could, years later, who was the only one there for my parents? I tell myself they did the best they could with what they knew, of course I have my own family now where we lay around listening to music and reading books, it’s wonderful.

          • Stanley Goldstein

            I’m glad you’re happy with your family, Cynthia. I do not have any living family, but for those in spirit. My biological family, I will have nothing to do with, for they are wicked and spiritually, unwise. Because the world now, is so infected with STD’s, I will not so much as kiss another human being. Life is dark, isolated and because of a crooked Christian Realtor, my life savings is tied up in an investment I haven’t been able to either profit from or free myself from in over 11 years. I am stuck in a horrible, red state, with unwise and nasty people all around. To add insult to injury, these wretches, in South Carolina, have just assisted in getting a man with the character of a mongrel, elected as my president. This is a painful time, indeed.

  • Melissa Martin

    The typos in this article make it near impossible to read.

  • Edie Homan

    I watched the documentary last night, and immediately took me aback the lack awareness of these ladies surroundings. I loved the way they carried on with any regard to appearances . It obviously shows some level of mental detachment from their reality. It showed me the level of human resiliency when faced to the need for survival. Although both ladies were groomedto be socialites and not trained in any practical vocation or profession they made it through with what they had. Wonderful, and Wonderus to look through the lens and observe their candide and spontaneous positive outlook on their circumstance.
    My husband was
    from NY and grew up in Long Island, and the accent and the manerisms reminded me of him and his family…